Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Chetan's avatar

So refreshing to see a balanced perspective from someone who is an SEO insider. The endless rants and tirades from most other quarters are quite tedious. Thank you for all the insights!

Expand full comment
Philipp Götza's avatar

I loved this Memo. In comparison to a lot of articles I read, you are one of few that tries to see all sides. At the beginning of the year I wrote about Google being under pressure in a lot of areas and talked about a narrative.

This narrative is not something anymore Google had to prevent, but is now facing.

When you said "we love to complain and still use products" I had to think of all the subreddits for multiplayer video games and wrestling. Everyone complains, yet still is a super heavy user and constantly buying into the product.

What I liked the most: Not shying away from signaling that you/we could all be wrong.

Do you have an opinion on the affiliates being demoted that seem to put in great work from the outside? There were a few examples I found surprising, but I didn't dig deep into the data or analyzed if they over-optimized. All I know is for a lot of queries in the US Google currently prefers the worse result. Worse = the content is objectively worse.

But, like you are alluding to, maybe it's actually what real people find the most helpful.

Expand full comment
4 more comments...

No posts